Thursday, September 11, 2025

Analysts call for extreme caution to restore normalcy

 Kathmandu, Sept. 9

With the fall of KP Sharma Oli-led government formed with the CPN-UML and Nepali Congress alliance following a nationwide protest put forth by 'GenZ' on Monday and Tuesday, a political void has been created amidst all institutions – with an exception of Nepali Army and a couple of other agencies – losing political legitimacy.

Meanwhile, governments at the provincial level have fallen and some local levels are facing extreme situations due to arson and vandalising by the protestors. Social media posts of many, including political analysts, expressed concerns to the fragile political situation, lost public trust in the state institutions and lack of decisive leadership in the part of the demonstrators. They asked a question, what next?

Since the prevailing Constitution of Nepal doesn't imaging the situation like this, it demands out of the book and innovative solutions that are accepted by the demonstrators and the society at large.

"Our constitution didn't imagine the situation whereby the prime minister resigned and the gap created subsequently. Now, the responsibility comes upon the president to find a way," said Krishna Khanal, a professor and political analyst.

He suggested that President Ramchandra Paudel, in consultation with the parties of the current struggle, should find a person to form an interim government to define the future political course of the country.

According to Prof. Khanal, primary concern of the institutions that have responsibility and public trust should address the demands raised from the ground. He denied the possibility of appointing any person from the existing political parties as the leader of the new government. "Now the country has a challenge to find a way that would address the demand of the people and wouldn't much disturb the constitutional provisions," he said while adding that such a way could be similar with the one the country adopted while extending the tenure of the Constitutional Assembly when it failed to formulate the constitution and dissolved in May 2012.

"We should apply extreme caution to maintain the political order," said Prof. Khanal.

While the constitution is not clear about the situation that erupted since Tuesday and there are no institution of political legitimacy in the country, many have rested their hopes with the Nepali Army.

 

Responsibility of Army and President

Political analyst Dr. Chandra Dev Bhatta said that the country shouldn't delay in forming a transitional government that would include civil society members and representatives of the youth protestors. Nepali Army and the President should take initiative for it, according to him.

"The immediate need of the country is a well-functioning government that would protect lives and public and private property. Since the legitimacy of existing political parties is over for now, credible institutions and persons should be brought onboard," said Dr. Bhatta.

It is likely that the country would be on the path of the Bangladesh – the protests, fall of the government and formation of a government in a leadership of socially trusted person that would include civil society members as well as the youth protestors.

Since the demonstrators have demanded their participation in the government, the government is likely to have their representative(s). However, since the leadership of the protests in Nepal – unlike Bangladesh - is not clear, the process might see some glitches.

Likewise, former ambassador Madhu Raman Acharya wrote on X that it would be appropriate for the President to assume authority until an alternative arrangement is made.

"With the Prime Minister having already resigned, it would be appropriate for the President to assume authority until an alternative arrangement is in place and to initiate a new process for the formation of a government in consultation with the protesters, the parties both inside and outside Parliament, as well as civil society," he said.

Meanwhile, the President Paudel in a statement on Tuesday evening appealed to all parties for dialogue. "Since the demands of the citizens in a democracy can be resolved through dialogue and negotiation with their representatives, I appeal to all parties to exercise restraint, not harm the country, and come to the negotiating table," reads a statement from the Office of the President.

 

'Final phase of success'

Later in the evening on Tuesday, the GenZ Alliance declared the protest to be in its 'final phase of success'.

In a statement circulated in the name of the Alliance, they demanded the formation of an interim government by dissolving the federal and provincial governments and hold a national GenZ National Conference.

They also called for a judicial commission to investigate all incidents of state oppression during the movement.

"A judicial commission will be formed to investigate all incidents of state oppression that occurred during the movement. Fundamental structures of the Nepal Constitution will be protected and progressive revisions would be made," said the GenZ Alliance while adding that during this process, they would be active in the reconstruction and production works.

A high-level commission will be formed to investigate and take legal action against former Prime Minister KP Sharma Oli, all party leaders, and all individuals who publicly supported them, read the statement.

The Nepali Army in its statement said that it is committed to protect the lives and proporty of Nepali citizens. As the protestors vandalized and torched the public properties including the Supreme Court, Singha Durbar, office of the Commission for the Investigation of Abuse of Authority, ministries, offices of the provincial and local governments and other agencies, public posts on social media condemned such activities.

Many historic monuments, buildings and artifacts have been turned into ashes, as a result. The GenZ Alliance through its statement has urged its supporters to refrain from vandalising the public property and return to safe locations. 

Published in The Rising Nepal daily on 10 September 2025.   

No comments:

Post a Comment

Featured Story

Govt prepares primary draft of DRR Policy

Kathmandu, Apr. 29: The government has prepared the preliminary report of the National Disaster Risk Reduction (DRR) Policy and Strategic ...